Insurance Woes

November 17th, 2016 by Potato

This post was drafted a while ago, when Wayfare was trying to get insurance in the spring. I was sitting on it partly because I was waiting for her to try another avenue (or just again with another year of stable post-mat-leave income) to get disability insurance and have a happier outcome. With recent events, it seems like just an extra kick in the pants.

“Insure all the things!” Wayfare was exclaiming after her two-hour meeting with the insurance saleslady. Considering she had gone in on a surgical strike mission to acquire some disability insurance, and came back loaded with pamphlets on all manner of insurance products yet lacking a quote on disability insurance, I have to commend the saleslady’s skill.

I have a very stoic view of insurance: if there’s a chance that some event will ruin us, we need to try to insure against it (and take reasonable precautions to prevent it from happening in the first place — note that in reconciling my philosophy and my actions, diet and exercise are not classified as reasonable precautions). Insurance is not something to buy to get a windfall in case of tragedy, and so we aim to self-insure wherever we can.

It’s also important to understand that we are in no way normal parents of a young child. Financially speaking, losing one parent or the other will not ruin us. We both have advanced degrees, we both work, and we have financial resources sufficient to cover over a year of cash burn if we had to take a prolonged leave of absence — plus as renters, we have the flexibility to reduce that cash burn with just a few months’ notice1. We are, as Miss Sunlife put it, “like a family of happy little squirrels, burying [our] nuts all over the yard in anticipation of winter.”

So my main fear is prolonged disability — because living our current extravagant lifestyle of having grass on both sides of our house (a detached house!) in Toronto requires two incomes, and one of us becoming disabled doesn’t free up the other to move on and move out in the tidy (if morbid) way that death would. Thus, disability was the one kind of insurance I did want to pay for, and we finally got off our butts to get a quote and make that happen.

But Wayfare came back full of weepy scenarios that appealed to emotion. What if something happened to little Blueberry? What would we do? Wouldn’t we want to be able to take some time off work to care for her or grieve? Yes — but doing so would not ruin us. We would survive and so we don’t need to insure against such a low-probability event. And if she died, I would not expect to long survive her.

“What if she got some childhood illness and then couldn’t get insurance of her own when she was an adult? If we get insurance on her now, then she can be automatically insured when she’s older and won’t have to go through this process.” Insuring the ability to get insurance is taking things too far for me. That’s second-order insurance. The fact that Miss Sunlife was able to make this argument stick firmly enough in Wayfare’s head for her to try to enthusiastically convince me of the need to insure our daughter demonstrates her level 8 insurance warlock sales skills. There were also pitches for critical illness insurance (which, reading the materials in hindsight, would not have covered this particular critical illness) and life insurance for us.

This crazy process started from a trip to the insurance saleslady looking for disability insurance for Wayfare, a self-employed person. She did not come back from that initial 2-hour meeting with a quote for disability to consider, so I told her to give up on Miss Sunlife and go talk to one of the nice people who stop by the blog who’re tuned in to the insurance world to figure things out and get a quote (or tell us what route we should really be taking to get one). But she’d already started with Miss Sunlife, and Miss Sunlife was nice, so she persevered. It took several more visits and lots of documentation archaeology (including lots of making Wayfare wait on hold to try to get the right documentation out of her doctors’ offices) to finally get a quote to decide on, and even then it was a quote, not a matrix of choices — each refinement to what we might want would require another visit. After many visits in person (because this can’t be done over the phone or online, obviously), we chose the options we wanted and needed, and put it through to the underwriters. Finally, Wayfare heard back: her application was denied. So she wasted hours of time and a few subway tokens, and the rejection letter doesn’t even give a reason (because her self-employment income history is variable with a recent mat leave, so she should try again in a year or two after that falls off? Because of pre-existing health issues and she shouldn’t waste her time again? Because something at the insurer got accidentally shredded and they didn’t want to ask for it again?).

It was a disappointing result, and a discouraging process: even if we were successful in getting insurance, it’s hard to believe that people who may not be fully sold on the need for disability insurance would put themselves through that massive time-sink. I didn’t even go through it myself (I am part of a group plan at work), but watching how much time it took, it will be hard for me to push freelancers I meet who really are under-insured to go take care of it.

1. This is because we live in way more space than is needed by a single-parent family — a 3-bedroom house with two freelancer office spaces. A (tragically) single-parent subset of our family could readily down-size to a 2-bdrm apartment. We also live in a massively expensive city in part to solve the two-body problem. One of us being out of the picture would free the other to move anywhere else, with a lower cost of living.

Trump and Investing

November 7th, 2016 by Potato

Someone taking the course asked this question, and I’ve seen it in multiple other forums lately: how would a Trump win in the election affect my investments? (Or similar ones like should I sell or should I delay investing until after the election?)

This is the sort of question that is very natural to ask, especially if you read the news or watch TV — the business entertainment channels are full of talking heads discussing these sorts of events and what effect they may have on markets. But remember, there is always a Trump (or Brexit, or sequestration, or imminent recession, or rate hike, etc., etc.).

It’s very easy to see some cause of uncertainty and doubt and let that translate into fear of investing (or staying invested). But there are some much better questions to ask yourself before selling in fear over a certain event:

  • Do I believe the evidence that short term events are extremely difficult and/or impossible to successfully trade?
  • Is the risk already “priced in”?
  • What happens if I’m wrong? For the 2016 US election example, the S&P500 is down about 3.5% on the month as I write this. How big of an effect would a Trump win be? What’s the likelihood of that? It may be partly priced in already – and then if Clinton wins, the market may snap back up. It may even snap up if Trump wins.
  • What happens if I’m right?
  • Do I want to open that door? This is perhaps the most important question of them all. Trading on short-term fears is a behavioural finance mistake – you have a long-term plan that involves expecting events like this and riding through them. Even if this time you have correctly read the situation and have insight others in the market lack and you are positioned to make money (or avoid a loss) from your brilliance, do you want to open the door to this kind of activity?

Remember, most of the time most people get these kinds of moves wrong and will end up doing worse than if they had just held on. And getting one move right and making money at it can paradoxically be bad for your long-term plan, because it’s very hard to believe after that fact that you were either just lucky, or that this was that one time when your intuition/analysis was superior to everyone else’s. So the next time some short-term event comes along, you’ll be more likely to make a hypothesis and react, rather than sticking to your long-term plan. Even if you lose more money on the next three events than you saved on the first short-term trade, if you’re like most humans you’ll still be tempted to act on your feelings for the fourth event, because that first success convinced you that this was a smart thing to do.

This philosophy and investing approach means that there will be a time when you “just knew” that some terrible thing was going to happen before it did. You may kick yourself for not acting… but try to remember all that other things you “just knew” were going to happen but didn’t. So maybe you will lose some money next week because of fear surrounding the election (or maybe not – who knows!). But by sticking to your long-term plan anyway you’ll also save yourself from that time when the talking heads said you had to stay in cash after selling out in 2008 until the March 2009 bottom was “re-tested” or that other time when the bad jobs report surely signalled the start of a new recession.

Visualizing Data and Situations

September 28th, 2016 by Potato

Recently I got an email from Chris (his mailing list is actually good, BTW). He includes these neat sketches to try to understand his money and see things in a new light. A few weeks ago was one on his money infrastructure, which I’m hoping he’ll turn into a post for non-subscribers to see, but the one I want to touch on this week is a sketch of his irregular income through the year that he just sent out. It’s basically a bubble chart (though he uses squares instead of bubbles), showing how his confirmed income varies through the year.

RagstoReasonable irregular income figure

I saw that and thought neat, this is presenting some information in a way that will make people think.

I then thought “this can be presented differently, especially if I would want to use this information to plan my freelancing activities.”

In that figure, he has as his independent axis (x-axis) “time available to make money”, with the months scattered all around, and expenses running up the left side. But you can immediately see a strong relationship between the size of the boxes (committed income) and time available to make money — when he has less committed income, he has more time to make money, which is not very surprising and perhaps not what you want to take away from the chart.

Instead of scrambling the months, we can rearrange it chronologically.

He also has expenses and income as separate variables for each month. Sometimes it’s useful to think about those as separate things, especially when you can attack them from either side. But if you’ve more-or-less figured out your expense side and want to focus on making more money (as the initial x-axis implies), we can instead plot the difference between expenses and income — when are the shortfalls? How do the shortfalls line up with opportunities to make more money? Are there blocks or are they one-off months in islands of pre-committed business?

RagstoReasonable variable income chronological

So now with net income, time available, and time through the year plotted I could use this layout to start planning my side business activities.

As Chris, I could see that from November through February I have a large shortfall in budget, and a decent amount of free time, so this period I’d try to book up with freelance work, with some possibly spilling into March to wind-up (and I’d have to be done for the big Opera period in April). Then in May some time opens up, but the motivation to get stuff going won’t be high as there will still be positive net income. However, there will be minor shortfalls all through the summer with lots of time to spare, so assuming that Chris needs to account for lead time to book clients, he would use the time in May to do that business development, and then work freelance lots through the summer. Then come October, Chris really will have no time to spare, so booking business for the Nov – Feb period will likely have to wait until November (and even then the time is not as open). That means he’ll need to budget to deal with that big shortfall expected in Nov, as it’ll take some time for the freelance income to pick up then.

So here I’ve abstracted away a variable — I’m assuming that I’ve already dealt with planning my [Chris’] expenses, and am trying to visualize the data in a way to help me manage a freelance career on top of a singing career. And this may be a more useful visualization for that particular problem.

But that doesn’t make this a better general approach. After all, some of Chris’ expenses may be variable and flexible, and he would want to plan out when to schedule those based on when there will be money in his accounts after paying gigs, and when he will have time. In that case he’ll want to see income and expenses separately — indeed he may want to collapse income and time available to focus on time through the year and then have different bubbles overlaid for different kinds of expenses. Then he could plop some expenses in different places to see what would fit best for him. For example, he may want to schedule his dental appointments in November and May, when he has time and money after his busy October and April gigs. And indeed, he had just such a visualization sketched out when I chatted with him about this.

With some things in life, especially personal finance, there are many more ways to look at data and to try to present it in ways that help guide different decisions. I’m trying to make use of this more in the course — there’s lots of line and scatter graphs, but also a few simple sketches and pictograms with bunnies. But there’s lots more room to go, and I’m excited to see other people sketching things out in different ways

Anyway, stay tuned to ragstoreasonable as I’m sure Chris is going to come out with some neat visualizations and sketches soon (peerpressurepeerpressurepeerpressure).

Indexing and Valeant/Nortel

September 20th, 2016 by Potato

An active portfolio manager recently criticized index investing because Valeant became the biggest TSX component and then blew up, as Nortel did in ages past. The implication being that active investing would have avoided concentrating so much into a stock like that.

This is a flawed argument. First, he’s suggesting that active management could have avoided the Valeant collapse, which we can’t just take as a given. After all, it didn’t get that way because of the index investors — Valeant became the biggest TSX component because on average active investors gave it that valuation. Now, it’s possible (especially in this case of a cross-listed stock with an international presence) that American active investors are what drove the price up, leading to its over-weight status in the Canadian index (even if Canadian mutual funds didn’t hold it to that proportion), or a small minority of Canadian active investors just going crazy for the stock drove up its proportion in the index, but sparing the portfolios of most active investors.

Whatever, it happened: Valeant became huge then blew up1. That makes 2015 an easy comparison year for active funds versus the index, right? And indeed, over half of Canadian equity funds managed to out-perform the index that year, a massive increase over the typical numbers. However, despite the gimme at the end of the period, nearly two-thirds of funds still under-performed on a 5-year basis — this is clearly not a fatal flaw in index investing.

Which makes it a really insidious sort of criticism because there is a nugget of truth in there. It would be better if bubbles never formed and blew up, but that’s too hard to avoid in practice, and over the long term (which is what matters), indexing is still the better bet. Even if every once in a while the indexes do throw a soft pitch inefficiency to the active investors, it’s too hard to take advantage of (net of fees) consistently enough to win out.

Oh, and while 2015 was a pretty good year for Canadian active investors versus the average, note further down in the report that 85% of US equity funds under-performed the S&P500 that year, and 99% under-performed on a 5-year basis.

Every now and then index investing will include blow-ups like this (or miss run-ups), making an easy comparable for the active managers. Despite the odd case of that happening, over the long term index investing has been the better choice.

1. Fun fact: VRX is the biggest near-miss in my active investing portfolio. Screwing that trade up is perhaps the strongest signal that I’m too busy for even a small active “play” portfolio and it’s time for 100% indexing for me. I decided to short VRX in August 2015, after the AZ Value posts but before Philidor hit the news. I put in an order to buy some puts, but was too stubborn to cross the spread. My bid did not get filled at the end of the day, and then I was too busy with work to enter it again the next few weeks. Then the Philidor revelations came out and I was dumb enough to think that falling from ~$300 to ~$240 meant that I was chasing it down and most of the negative news was baked in. If I had just been willing to cross the spread and pay like $20 more for my puts, or even to come back and keep the bid alive, I would have had about a 15X return on that short. It is no small source of embarrassment and rage and kicking myself that I actually had done the research and entered an order, and still managed to miss out. As Wayfare said, “there’s this great book on passive index investing you should read…”

The Index Card

September 15th, 2016 by Potato

In looking for other descriptions of simple ways to plan and manage your finances, I recently read The Index Card.

The backstory is neat:

When University of Chicago professor Harold Pollack interviewed Helaine Olen, an award-winning financial journalist and the author of the bestselling Pound Foolish, he made an off­hand suggestion: everything you need to know about managing your money could fit on an index card. To prove his point, he grabbed a 4″ x 6″ card, scribbled down a list of rules, and posted a picture of the card online. The post went viral.

An early version of the card is available online at many places, including this story at NPR. The final book tweaked things a bit, but from a quick note surprisingly little changed.

I love the idea of a card like this: a simple set of guiding principles, presented in a really simple way (even the medium of the index card helps reinforce the idea that this shouldn’t be too scary).

However, I can’t say I’d recommend the book for Canadian readers: beyond the real basics of paying off your credit card every month, most of the book is really geared to Americans. With lots of focus on 401(k) plans, 30-year mortgages, and health insurance woes, big portions of this book don’t carry over well across the border. I also wasn’t a fan of the third person voice shifting between the two co-authors. “While working on Pound Foolish, Helaine… Since publishing Pound Foolish, Helaine has sat through… When at the University of Chicago, Harold…”

But let’s move beyond the book to focus on the concept of the index card.

There are lots of things you could include in a high-level summary or set of guiding principles that fit on an index card. And you might build a card differently depending on whether you’re trying to create one for yourself (a la the One-Page Financial Plan), or create a general one to hand out to university students as they graduate or even the public at large.

What specific items to include (and which to exclude), and how to set up such a card is up for a lot of thought and debate. For example, the eponymous index card that Harold made had “pay your credit card balance in full”, but that came after a bunch of stuff on investing and saving. If you’re already saving and investing, do you need that credit card advice, or can it be assumed? If you need to spell out paying off your credit card, shouldn’t it be item #1? And if you have to spell out how credit cards work, do you also need something about car loans? Same with investing: if you already have a point about investing in low-cost index funds, do you need a separate one about not investing in individual stocks? His card also had something political but nothing about donating to The Princess Margaret Cancer Foundation and other charities, which to some people is more important.

There are lots of ways to try to tweak that original card, or to set out to make your own.

Here’s where you need to know your audience: what are the important things to highlight and spell out, and what can be assumed or implied? This is a lot easier if you’re writing a card for yourself than if you’re trying to make the perfect generic card.

Then I think a really good idea is to remember what index cards were originally for and build that in. For those of you who are too young to remember (and those who don’t have an antique card catalogue in your living room to help remind you), before computerized databases and indexing, meta-information about books and other materials at the library was kept on index cards. So you could flip through a stack of index cards to find something you were looking for, then that would point you to the long-from material (a book or file somewhere). Your index card can do just that too: you can write it down on an actual card or use Word or Google Docs to write it out, then link to more information somewhere else. Then if you have a point to make and it’s debatable whether it’s a stand-alone point or really a sub-element of another point, you can include it in the detailed breakdown linked.

So your short summary of personal finance principles can fit on one small piece of cardstock, demonstrating that it’s not all that complicated and that you can do it. But you can link to the more detailed practical information you’ll need from time to time to actually follow and implement those principles. I did something of the sort with the reading guide, but you can set your index card up to link to your own shorter, more relevant summaries.

Here’s how I would set up a generic index card:

  1. Understand why this is important to you. [References: Sandi’s Spanish River talks, posts, One-Page Financial Plan [sic], Wealthing Like Rabbits]
  2. Get out of debt, and stay out of debt. [pay off credit cards, debt blogs, Gail Vaz Oxlade books, etc]
  3. Create a budget, and live below your means. [budgeting tools, different approaches, more books, rent vs buy resource, cars and other big-ticket item resources]
  4. Have an emergency fund and disaster-proof your life. [resources on emergency funds, insurance, Stop Over-Thinking Your Money chapter]
  5. Plan for retirement, even if you love your job. [resources]
  6. Invest for the future in low-cost, broadly diversified funds, using employer matching, TFSAs, RRSPs, etc. [Value of Simple, Practical Investing Course, other resources]
  7. Automate as much as possible to circumvent bad behaviour and improve odds of success [resources on behavioural finance, creating processes, paying yourself first, etc.]
  8. Get help when you need it from people working for your best interest [directory, other resources]

And just like nearly every review of The Index Card suggests changes to the card Harold originally created, this generic card has a lot of room for personalization and discussion & debate. For example, I assumed a lot of things could just be folded under “create a budget”, which otherwise might be rich points of discussion and education on their own. I didn’t mention taxes anywhere, nor pensions or retirement income, but maybe a generic card should include “file your taxes every year”. Nothing about sharing money with a spouse, educating your kids, or paying financial literacy forward, though those could also get top billing depending on the audience. And I could include an ur-point about financial literacy: it’s important, and it’s up to you to learn enough to protect yourself and get by in this world.

What would you include on your own card?