On Robo-advisors

November 19th, 2015 by Potato

One of my main focuses these days is helping people to get their money invested in a way that works for them for the long term. That’s why I started coaching people, and why I wrote The Value of Simple, to teach people how to do that on their own. Lots and lots of people have found it really useful and I’m very proud of that. Many can and should go the DIY route, but not everyone will want to or be well-suited to that method.

The robo-advisors sound like an excellent alternative, especially when combined with a fee-for-service planner for the complex bits that fall outside investing. I really like the idea of robo-advisors, but I had some reservations when they first came out. I’m glad to say that they are by and large knocking down my objections (in particular, moving from esoteric high-cost underlying funds to lower-cost broadly diversified portfolios, lower minimums, etc., though all-in pricing remains a challenge).

So far when someone has needed a hands-off DIY-ish solution like this, I’ve mostly been pointing them to Tangerine (covered in the book) in large part because Tangerine is a known quantity. A “known-known” if you would. I know first-hand that Tangerine is easy and smooth and painless, and what the tax statements will look like, that it minimizes analysis paralysis, and that all four asset classes are held in a single fund structure so rebalancing doesn’t lead to realized capital gains/losses in non-registered accounts1. Even just a few months ago, for people with smaller accounts Tangerine was really not any more expensive so it was an easy recommendation. As the robos have started using cheaper underlying funds and offering free passes to really small accounts, the cost difference has grown and the robos look more attractive. For people with larger accounts it was often a temporary recommendation, like “go with Tangerine for now and see what shakes out next year — you can switch then when there’s more clarity.” Note that I’m not trying to fear-monger with statements like that: I’m concerned with the customer experience rather than the safety of the money (which is held by reputable custodians covered by CIPF). Rest assured that even if the plethora of firms start to consolidate, or get swallowed by the big banks, or whatever, your investments there will be safe2.

There are still a few minor questions and quibbles3, but I’m the kind of person who will always have minor quibbles so at this point there’s no point in holding back from recommending them for investors who see value in their services. The main thing that’s missing is that first-hand experience, because no matter how easy they are to use it’s always handy to have a third-party walk-through to reassure people that it will all be ok, that the real-world situation lives up to the marketing4.

I wanted to make a grand guide to robo-advisors, kind of like a supplement to the book to compare them, including first-hand experience. I pitched it as a multi-part blog post guide as well as a flashy PDF summary. But I haven’t been able to secure the support to make that happen, and it’s too late in the year to include anything about tax reporting even if I was able to make that happen today. I still think a head-to-head mystery shop comparison would be really valuable, and I hope someone puts in the time and capital to do it (especially to do it in a way that includes challenging the services/concierges with dumb questions)… but it doesn’t look like I’m the right person to do it5.

Good behaviour is an essential part of long-term investing success, and is one area where I’m still not quite sure where the robo-advisors fall. On the one hand they largely use best practices to create broadly diversified portfolios and take away all the performance-chasing and what-not that individual investors and active managers are equally guilty of. Set it, forget it, automate it — they sound awesome. When markets roiled at the end of the summer they send out reassuring emails and had their staff standing by the phones. However, they also offer smartphone apps. At CPFC15, the CEO of one robo-advisor proudly proclaimed that a third of their clients check their smartphone app daily.

A third? Every day? I threw up in my mouth a bit.

That is just not a good thing for investor behaviour (but great for “engagement”). Even if there isn’t a big “panic sell” button in the app, frequently checking on a portfolio makes people feel the market ups and downs more vividly, which might lead them to do something drastic down the road (indeed, attempting to panic or alter my risk profile on the fly was something I wanted to check in the robo-advisor review/mystery shop to see how they handled the situation). Yes, Tangerine has an app, but it’s designed for your chequing account and it takes a few taps to get down to see your investments, and even there they only show you the balance in your investment account, with no flashy graphs of recent market drops or big red daily change numbers, and no individual segment reporting so you have to work a bit harder to activate your lizard brain.

But whatever, there’s nothing to do but see how things shake out, and with how fast things are moving those could be totally redesigned by next week.

So if you’re looking for a lower-cost way to get the investment implementation part of your finances handled — and don’t want to do a full DIY implementation — go ahead and check out the robo-advisors, and let me know how it goes. Remember that getting your savings invested is just part of the personal finance and planning challenge. A big, scary one to be sure, but just a part — your plan will be important for creating the context for those investments (like risk tolerance) and will be important for a bunch of other stuff unrelated to investing (like sleeping at night).


1 – and that they’re not playing silly buggers with esoteric asset classes and slicing-and-dicing, which I personally dislike but which I suppose I have to admit is not inherently evil.
2 – well, safe as can be expected: you may be inconvenienced, and still subject to the risks of the investments themselves — you’ll get your share of the ETF units back (or their market value at the time), but your principal is not guaranteed, just like investing anywhere else.
3 – like this post from WealthSimple. I’m not sure such expertise exists at all — and given that the fund in question under-performed a vanilla bond index when managed by the so-called professionals, I’m highly skeptical that if such expertise does exist that a small firm like WS will suddenly possess it in-house… and Eric Kirzner has been there since the beginning, which I should stop ranting about in the footnote. I will always find quibbles.
4 – to spot the unknown unknowns.
5 – in large part because I’m cheap and while the robo-advisors are relatively inexpensive, they’re still going to cost me a few hundred bucks more than DIY costs, on top of the PITA factor of actually doing it and then dealing with all these open accounts everywhere (which would all be non-registered accounts as my TFSA is full). And apparently I’m not persuasive enough to get them to sponsor an editorially independent comparison. [note to the footnote: I had not yet asked WealthSimple, in case they’re reading this and are all like “what, we never got such a request from Potato.” I figured the other rejections were enough to kill the idea.] {note to the note to the footnote: I had thought about trying to do a really small kickstarter, but as much as I think this sort of thing would be useful to the community, I don’t think anyone wants to fund it.}

Drinks with Borrowell

October 16th, 2015 by Potato

Before CPFC15, Borrowell hosted a drinks and appetizers mixer thing, and I got a chance to ask them a few questions about what they do (and full disclosure: they fed me snacks and a coke).

In particular, I was interested in how they approve borrowers, what their risk processes were, etc., and whether they were using any of the data available online to create fancy algorithms for approving loans. Interestingly (and reassuringly, if you’re an investor of theirs) they use very conventional risk metrics. Transunion and Equifax have been in business a long time, and it’s hard to beat credit scores and debt service ratios for determining risk and ability to repay debt. They can look at other factors to provide small tweaks or help identify potential fraud, but the basics are at work here.

Co-incidentally, after I got back I saw this great quote tweeted out: “Every company with a smart way of making loans others won’t later turns out to have a dumb way of making loans others won’t,” which got to the heart of what was on my mind as I was first hearing about Borrowell and innovative lending. And not that I have anything at stake, but it’s what I worry about for fintech start-ups: innovation is great, but there is over-innovation, and while it may be possible to find the decent gems the big banks reject out of hand and lend to them profitably, it’s hard and creates blow-up risk. And having some of these guys blow-up is not in anyone’s interest. There has been some talk about leveraging “big data” to make better loans, but it’s hard to do much more than tweak what already works, and it’s nice to see in practice that the fundamentals are at play there. They also mentioned that there’s a lot of tension between the underwriters and the marketing team, which is essential IMHO (if the underwriters aren’t killing the marketing team’s buzz something has gone wrong — indeed, if the underwriters aren’t separate from the marketing team, something has gone wrong).

The pitch was quite good: they’re not trying to make loans that no one else will, but rather to make it more convenient for people with decent (if not stellar) credit to get a loan without having to go in to a bank, without having to wait a long time to hear back, and without having to risk facing their neighbourhood branch manager to receive bad news. Also, that their main competition was as much credit cards (who do no risk analysis and just lend at high rates to all comers) as banks, especially since banks these days are mostly interested in pushing lines of credit instead of short-term (~3 year) amortizing loans.

Finally we talked for a bit about behaviour and how they can help. It was good to hear that they’re setting up referrals to debt management programs to point people towards if they get flagged by the system during an application as being over-stretched or in distress. And focusing on small-scale, amortizing loans (i.e. not revolving lines of credit, which are just about all the big banks offer these days), they can be more useful for those people trying to get out of high-interest debt.

It’s not a service I anticipate readers here to use — while the rates will depend on individual circumstances, and they will likely be a damned sight better than a credit card or subprime auto loan, they won’t be as good as a line of credit at a bank if you’re in good financial shape (which I assume all of you are) — but nice to know it exists.

The DIY Investing Environment

October 6th, 2015 by Potato

Had a great chat on Because Money about who might be well-suited to being a DIY investor, what traits you might want to focus on as a DIY investor, etc., which should be airing later in October. I want to use this post to go down a side alley we didn’t talk much about in the episode.

Only ~13% of Canadians are DIY investors, and most of them started in the last 5 years. While we didn’t quite agree on precisely how many people should/could use a DIY approach, we were all giving estimates well above that figure. There’s a lot of room for improvement.

So what is stopping people from becoming DIY investors, what are the barriers? I like to think in terms of intrinsic and external factors.

For external factors, the environment has been getting a lot friendlier for individual DIY investors over the past few years: low-cost ETFs increase the cost savings available and make it very easy to create broadly diversified portfolios — whatever your position on efficient markets and index investing, it’s undeniably easier to implement than value or dividend or day-trading or whatever DIY strategy, which is part of why gurus like Warren Buffet recommend it for regular people. Brokerages like Questrade offering free purchases makes those ETFs accessible to investors with smaller starting portfolios, and even the bank-affiliated brokerages have extended $10 commissions to all customers without a net worth test. On the other end of the spectrum, Tangerine and the robo-advisors have made it very simple and easy to be a DIY investor — about as easy as a visit to the local bank branch salesperson/”advisor” was, at less than half the cost and without having to find a slushy parking spot in February.

The environment and the tools available to be DIY investors are quite good now — massive leaps ahead of what potential DIYers faced just a few decades ago.

So the remaining barriers are inside people’s heads. Not just their behaviour, but their biases and assumptions that are stopping them from starting, or even looking into whether they should start. Things like assuming you need to be rich before you think about investing, that you need to be a genius or use a lot of math, or get some kind of license or certification to purchase investments on your own.

All of these are easily solvable with a bit of education. Of course I have my own solution for that in the form of The Value of Simple (plus this other thing that I’m working on).

And of course, doing DIY investing doesn’t mean you have to do everything on your own. You can find planners, accountants, coaches, etc. to help with any parts you’re not comfortable with.

So there are a great many people out there — maybe half of you reading this or more — who could move into doing DIY investing to save on fees, or get started with investing in the first place. So what are you waiting for?

As a side point to this side point, there was a bit of disagreement on what DIY is, and I’ll just say I’m not too worked up on the semantics either way. In particular, the question was raised as to whether using a roboadvisor or all-in-one fund with automatic rebalancing like Tangerine was really DIY? For myself, I would count them as part of the DIY route as they still require following your own plan, picking your own product (even if that product is just Tangerine premix #2) and not getting sold on the fund of the week, pushing money to your investments vs having a salesperson trying to pull, and above all, reaping the main benefit of DIY: lower costs.

Anyway, there are a few Because Money episodes from season 2 up now, and be sure to watch for my guest appearance comes out later this month.

Non-Registered Investment Tracking Spreadsheet

September 8th, 2015 by Potato

In a non-registered account you will at some point have to pay tax on any capital gains, and you have to report that amount yourself. You’ll need some method to properly* track your cost base so that when you sell you know how much of a gain (or loss) to claim on your taxes. [TL;DR — click here to download the spreadsheet]

I often get asked whether tracking ACB yourself is really necessary. Brokerages and mutual fund dealers will track your book value for you, and most of the time they’re accurate. So you could save yourself a fair bit of effort by just relying on their calculation for tax purposes, especially if all of your accounts are in one place. However, if you have holdings of the same ETF/stock/fund at different brokers (e.g., if I had an account at TD Waterhouse holding VDU and one at Questrade holding VDU) then they wouldn’t talk to each other and there would be no option other than to track it myself. They also don’t seem to catch superficial losses. The bigger issue though is that the brokers sometimes make mistakes in the book value calculations, and it is ultimately your responsibility to report correctly to the CRA.

So the only proper advice I can give is to carefully track it yourself to double-check your broker/mutual fund dealer because the onus on being correct will fall on your shoulders. But that said, I do personally know a few people who do not track it themselves and who come out fine (either because the broker/dealer gives them correct information, or because even when there are errors they don’t get audited) — in the real world it’s very tempting (and understandable) to take the free tracking offered. With mutual funds there’s one less step for information to go wrong (at least if you’re buying funds from the issuing company, like TD e-series at TD), so it’s even more likely to be correct, but you’ll never know if you’re the one unlucky customer with a bad book value calculation until you get audited. And of course, the errors they’re making could be costing you money. If you do let the company track for you, at least be sure to hold on to the statements you’ll need to re-do the calculation if it comes to it.

Tracking it is not all that hard a mathematical exercise, the tricky part comes in being careful to put everything on the right side of the ledger and to follow-through each year. There can be a lot of transactions to put in there, including annoying “phantom” distributions that change your cost base but didn’t actually show up in your brokerage statement. There are a number of tools out there to try to help you with your ACB, including a web-based calculator and spreadsheets from several sources, like this classic (if sparse) one from the old Canadian Capitalist blog.

I myself use a very barebones spreadsheet similar to CC’s, but it’s not a great model for others to use because it depends on me knowing what it is I’m doing with the ACB calculation to create each new row as needed.

So I’ve created a new template that I hope is better suited to the target audience for the Value of Simple (click here to get the sheet). This sheet assumes that you’ll have a fairly typical experience of buying/DRIPing many shares/units over time, and only occasionally selling. So rather than save space and intersperse all the transactions as they happen, it’s set up to go with your workflow. I assume that you’ll go through various modes. First you’re buying and holding, then it summarizes your ACB for a sale with all the adjustments from RoC and reinvested capital gain distributions, then you make a sale (or series of sales), and then get back into buying mode. Then each of your funds gets its own tab.

As with many ACB trackers, the superficial loss rule can throw you for a loop. It’s hard to catch everything that can trigger a superficial loss, so there is no automatic check for it so you won’t have a false sense of security — you’ll have to catch those situations yourself (though there is a sample of that case so you can see how to adjust your cost base for when it does happen).

* – I often stress the importance of tracking this yourself. That’s because it’s so tempting to not track it properly and independently and rely on the “book value” or “cost” listed on your brokerage statement. Most of the time this will be correct and you could have saved some record-keeping effort. However, sometimes it won’t be, and then you’ll be mis-reporting to the CRA. It’s analogous to tracking your TFSA contributions yourself: the CRA online tool or phone reps may be able to accurately tell you how much room you have left, but in the rare case where that’s wrong the penalties will still fall in your lap. So I’ll try my best to tell you how to track and report properly, and make it as easy as possible; if you choose not to and get audited, at least you’ll know what you did wrong!

Investing Should Be Boring

August 27th, 2015 by Potato

Stamp collecting is pretty much the definition of boring. Yet stamps are useful things that enable exciting mail to happen. Most people just care that they can put a stamp on an envelope and a birthday card or letter will show up in someone else’s mailbox a few days later. So if we had some big national collective worry that not enough people were getting birthday cards, I don’t think we’d start by trying to get people excited about stamps in and of themselves — we’d just want to get people using them. And to stretch the metaphor, we may see people using high-priced couriers and worry that they’re not getting value for money. Maybe FedEx comes right to your door, but for just a bit of effort to walk down to the post office and source an envelope yourself, you could get your mailing done a lot cheaper.

Because you read the post title, you know this is turning into a stretched analogy to investing.

A few months ago a writer for the Globe contacted me for a short interview1 around the premise of how to make investing more exciting.

I think investments and the whole process of investing are — to most people — pretty boring. And that’s a good thing: investing should be boring. No one’s going to text their friends about putting their money in a diversified, balanced portfolio with reasonable fees and deciding on a level of professional advice that they think they need and is appropriate and delivers value. It’s like watching a kettle of water boil or paint dry or grass grow, except instead of a few minutes, hours, or days to see some action you’re talking decades for your investments to do their job for you. It’s beyond the scope of our every-day sense of scale. Fortunately, with index funds and automatic purchases the boredom doesn’t have to be noticeable, either: you can do some reading and come up with a basic plan over a weekend or two, and then your plan only takes a few minutes or hours per year to maintain — the boring investing stuff can become a background process — so you can get on with your life and do all the fun, exciting stuff you want to do.

And then that’s ultimately what the point of investing is: to help you meet your goals. Watching your child graduate from university, that’s exciting — and having the resources to help pay for your child’s post-secondary education helps make that happen. Clocking out at your job for the last time and knowing you’ll have the money to enjoy a comfortable, stress-free retirement, that’s exciting — and signing up for a company RRSP match and investing some savings yourself can help make that happen. Having an emergency fund to act as a cushion so you’re not constantly stressed out about your financial situation… ok, well that one isn’t terribly exciting, either, but it’s nice and a lot better than the alternative.

Putting money away and investing it — using your RESP, RRSP, and TFSA — will help get you to those exciting goals, but that part of it is dull dull dull2. And that last point about having an emergency fund for security so you know that if your furnace breaks down you can handle it speaks to the other side of the coin for not trying too hard to solve the problem of your investments being boring: they should help remove stress from the rest of your life, not add to it. There are some weeks where boring would be just fantastic.

So rather than trying to shift the way you view investments from boring and stressful to some form of exciting, I think they should be boring — complete with all the wonderful things that being boring brings.

As for getting motivated enough to take that first step towards investing, instead of gamifying investing or finding some way to make it feel exciting, instead I suggest asking yourself what are some things you’d like your investments to do for you? What are some of your dreams or goals that your investments may help you realize?

For me, I like to view my investments as a great pool of potential, all the future stuff I will want and need, just gestating and developing. Somewhere in there is the seed of the new car I’m planning to get in about 8-10 years when my current one (now 5 years old) is ready to be replaced — it’s maybe got vestigial gills and a tail, but it’s starting to take shape. There’s all the stuff I’m going to have in retirement, which are little more than blastocytes out there in this stretched metaphor, but the seeds have been sown, and I’ll just have to wait to see how they develop.

1. Given the time that’s passed, I suppose it’s safe to say that that interview is never going to see the light of day and I’m not scooping anyone by sharing some of what I said.
2. Well, for most people. Some of us, like stamp collectors and baseball fans, are totally engrossed in this activity which to outsiders is totally boring.