Coping Mechanisms for Budgeting

July 1st, 2013 by Potato

Budgeting is a necessary part of life: resources are finite, and we have to allocate them somehow. Though some may revel in the min-maxing challenge of budgeting, it is at its heart a somewhat painful process of self-denial. So what mechanisms do people use to stay on budget? There are mechanical ones, such as using jam jars and cash, but for most people with access to credit psychological control must be exerted.

There are several coping mechanisms to deal with the psychic strain of not buying what you want. Myself, I think of life in terms of video games, with money being the points I can spend on my character, and there are simply some areas of spending that result in more happy points being accrued than in others, and I keep those trade-offs and opportunity costs in mind. I could buy this DVD, but I’d be happier saving that money for a video game next month. There are other similar rationalizing-based mechanisms out there, for instance you can focus on your long term goals and needs, and determine if a particular purchase fits into those.

Another one I’ve heard is to shift the money focus of budgeting to a dimension you may be more comfortable with, such as space in your house: if you buy whatever it is facing you, where will you fit it in your house (or hard drive)? There’s a limited amount of space, after all.

Wayfare presented me with a new one recently: when she comes across something awesome (a T-shirt on Think Geek, or a cute baby outfit in a store) she says to focus on the joy of the knowledge that it exists in the world, but know that you don’t need to have it in your house. It will still exist and be awesome and you can appreciate it even without spending money to have your own copy.

HOT.UN – American Hotel REIT

June 25th, 2013 by Potato

An investment idea a bit off the beaten track to discuss today: American Hotel REIT. This is a new REIT, still flush with cash from its IPO. They identified the small, economy hotel market as one that’s fragmented and where they could make a number of accretive acquisitions. It has purchased a set of low-end hotels from a private chain in the US. The neat thing about these hotels is that they are focused on serving railroad workers: Union Pacific pre-pays for the majority (74%) of the rooms so that their unionized employees can take their required rest periods, with some room-nights also booked by other railways.

I found it interesting that one of the words used to advertise their rooms was “dark” – not something you hear all the time to describe hotels, yet precisely what I want in a room where all I want to do is sleep and get back on the road.

In terms of cash flow, it’s a little difficult to say for sure because the REIT has only been operating the hotels for a few months, and only part of the cash raised in the IPO has been put to use. They are vastly overpaying because of that last factor, but I think we can assume they will build or buy more hotels, so we can estimate the payout for the long-term.

Looking at the statements from the hotels under the private label (available on SEDAR), it looks like if they can invest the remaining $26M they’ll have no problem covering the distribution with the raw cash flow. However, depreciation and amortization can’t be completely ignored – some maintenance capex will need to be put into keep these stick construction hotels up-to-date, especially since about 30% of the balance sheet is “equipment” with projected lifetimes of 5-15 years rather than real estate. Making some rough estimates as to what to reserve – the engineering report from the purchase identified ~$1M/year in projects – I figure that this portfolio is generating about $0.50-$0.70/unit in distributable cash. Assuming that the rest of the cash buys similar properties, that works out to about $0.80/unit – a bit under the announced payout of $0.90/unit.

Now, this is a recent IPO, and it’s nearly a sure bet that there will be more secondary offerings to come, so they may have purposefully set the distribution a bit high to attract investors. Personally, I’d prefer they set it too low and then adjust higher once the properties prove themselves, but that strategy doesn’t move shares on the TSX. Because of the virtual guarantee of future secondary offerings, the price isn’t likely to shoot through the roof. The newness and small size also means that it is not widely followed, possibly making for opportunity.

But if even being fairly conservative I figure they can support a 7% payout, with the only substantial risk being re-contracting with Union Pacific, then I’m pretty happy. Plus there’s a good chance that growth, synergies, and inflation can help them meet that $0.90 payout in short order – at least before deferring maintenance capex catches up to them. In this environment, an 8% yield with a bit of risk is a decent deal.

One area of conservatism is the loan on the properties: the private company holding the hotels before the purchase was borrowing at 3.5% with floating-rate mortgages, but HOT.UN’s new financing is 5-year fixed at 4.85%, which is nearly ten cents per unit of cashflow right there. Lowering their borrowing costs (e.g., by growing larger and becoming more credit-worthy) could help make the distribution safer.

Disclosure: currently long HOT.UN. Note that this is a new, small, illiquid REIT with many risk factors (e.g., actually putting the cash to productive use; subsequent/dilutive offerings).

On Your Final Career and Financial Education

June 21st, 2013 by Potato

One thing I struggle with is convincing people of the importance of certain elements of personal finance. I’m pretty sure it is important, and the struggle is not that I need to change minds per se, but that I need to find a way of conveying the message that resonates so people follow-through. In particular just convincing people of the very basic need to take some time to learn a bare modicum of this stuff for themselves. After all, time is at such a premium, and personal finance can be so dull.

So consider this: if you aim to be retired sometime around 60-70, and will live into your 90’s, you could be retired for 30-some years. The money to support you will in large part come from your investments. In a way, investing is going to be your career – it’s where the money to live off is going to come from in retirement. Indeed, of all the careers you will have over your life, being a professional investor/retiree will likely be the one with the longest tenure.

That’s not to say that it will be the most intensive career: you’re not going to be sitting in front of a trading desk 9-5 in your golden years. If you follow a passive strategy it might only take a few minutes a month while you sell down investments, move cash to your chequing account to spend, plus a few hours at tax time. But in terms of putting food on the table, it will be nearly as important as whatever it is you’re supposed to be doing now when you’re reading this.

It’s going to be so important, and you’re going to be at it for so long – isn’t it worth spending the time to get some education on your future career?

Now of course this side career will become important long before retirement starts, when you’re in the accumulation phase, so you don’t want to wait until your retirement party to start looking into some good reads and continuing education. Think of it this way: you’re going to spend nearly 2000 hours/year working, for four decades of your life just to save the money you’ll need to live the rest of your life in comfort. How much of that time should be spent on learning the ins and outs of investing, saving, and retirement? Taking a full weekend (16 hours) and devoting it to reading and planning how you will manage your savings is a pretty miniscule amount of time compared to even a single year’s time spend accumulating said savings.

I know, there are always excuses: while you’re young (especially if you can get freelance work) you can always say that those hours could be better spent working to get more money to save, and doing just about anything else is more entertaining. Yet taking the time is an investment in its own right. So come on, give me a weekend.

It’s summer, you’re going to spend some time reading by the pool/beach/lake anyway (I hope), so let’s start with the reading. Here’s a really quick curriculum for you (and I welcome tweaking and book recommendations in the comments). Start by identifying what “year” you’re in for the summer curriculum.

Year 1: Budgeting and Debt. You need to get your household budget in order and tackle outstanding debt before you get into worrying about saving and investing. Dave Chilton’s The Wealthy Barber Returns covers a number of topics, including paying yourself first. “Debt gurus” abound with their books — I can’t make any personal recommendations (because they haven’t sent me review copies and it’s not my area of interest) but it’s a big market and a decent one shouldn’t be hard to find. For something lighter, maybe try Findependence Day by Jon Chevreau.

Spend your weekend skimming through one or a few of these. Dig up your statements to see where your money is going. Draw up your family budget, make a plan to pay down your debt. Call your bank (most have 24/7 phone lines) and set up a pay-yourself/your creditors-first plan if you need to. Take the rest of the year to get this right, get your emergency fund in place, and we’ll see you next summer for year 2.

Year 2: Saving and Investing. Not to be too self-promotional, but start by reading my book. It barely takes an afternoon to read all the way through, and from there you can decide if you need to read more, and in which direction (it has further reading recommendations inside). Exercises: determine your risk tolerance. Set up an investing account (brokerage or mutual funds, hopefully somewhere with low-cost index funds; non-registered, TFSA, and RRSP) — you can fill out the paperwork and place some calls, though opening an account from scratch may involve waiting a few weeks. Call to set up an automatic investment plan if needed.

Year 3: Planning. What will you do in retirement? How much will you spend, how long will you live, and what do you want to leave behind for family and charities? What’s a reasonable set of assumptions for rate of return? What are your tolerances and sensitivities? What’s your backup plan, and what signals will tell you you have to cut back on spending? Have you logged into Service Canada to see what your CPP benefit will be? You can get some books and spreasheets, but at this point there’s no shame in reaching out for a consultant/planner to help. I fully believe that most people can do this on their own with a reasonable time commitment and some reading material; but I recognize that can and will are different things so many may need to hire help (even if only because writing the cheque makes it painful enough to pay attention). Just be sure that you get value for money. Remember that at the end you should have a plan with multiple plans inside of it, including how you will adapt to various future possibilities.

As the years go by set aside some time (perhaps continue with a summer weekend each year) to review your plans and progress, and adjust course as needed. Consult: join forums, as talking will stimulate ideas. If your friends and family don’t view anything remotely related to money as taboo then discuss with them, it may even help spur them to get with the program and start training for their final career.

The Eternal PF Work-Life Debate

May 22nd, 2013 by Potato

It is an eternal debate: do we live for today or save for the future? Some kind of balance needs to be found, as living a hedonistic, spendthrift lifestyle only to end up spending your autumn years on government assistance is no good, but neither is playing the miser through your younger, healthier years just to die and leave it all behind.

I always thought I managed to walk this line fairly well: I work hard and save for the future, with a plan to retire earlier than 65 (after all, who knows what kind of shape I’ll be in by 60), but still enjoy the moment. I’m aware of the power of compounding, and have internalized the math that saving & investing a dollar today means I can spend three in retirement. Inversing that, taking a year off from work now might mean I’d have to tack on 3-5 more working years at the end of my career before retiring.

That’s pretty simple logic on the opportunity cost of taking time off — and it gets even worse when you consider the potential damage of a gap to my career. So I’ve never really considered taking time off without a damned good reason to. Heck, even on my vacations I tend to find side projects to work on, even if they’re not the most profitable post hoc (e.g., book). But now that Blueberry is on the scene I start to wonder.

I missed my daughter’s first steps today. That’s not such a surprise, as even Wayfare has missed some of her firsts (she seems to show off for grandma), and I’m at work all day. Yet it kind of puts a sharp focus on something that’s really been bugging me about my job: I spend so much time commuting and working that I hardly see the whole reason I’m going through the whole mess. A few months ago when she was into her “stranger danger” phase, I went a full week without seeing her, and when I finally did she freaked out and cried because she didn’t recognize her dad. So missing her first steps is a moment that does make me — for perhaps the first time — step back and seriously consider taking some time off from my career.

It’s also a bit of a timely issue because Wayfare’s mat leave has run its course, and yet Blueberry is still too young for daycare, leaving us searching for childcare options. It is heart-wrenching to even think of handing over our little girl to some stranger to watch over, yet it is also difficult to get by on just one income, particularly in this city. I know eventually she will have to go off to spend more time being raised by strangers than with us — at school if not daycare — but it doesn’t stop me from wondering if taking a year off now and draining my savings might be totally worth it. It sure seems nicer to spend some time at home taking care of my baby than to be able to take more time off at the end of my career, when the house will be cold and empty.

And this is the age when I want to be there for her: at 12 she won’t want to see “Da”, she’ll be at school for most of the day and then want to disappear into her room with a book or video/holo game when she’s not. Right now she’s thrilled to have me around, and the world is a magical wonderful place full of adventure and discovery. I want to be there to see her point to a bird singing in a tree and exclaim “Bir!” or to a passing jet and do the same*. I want to watch her dig through her bag of toys until she finds a match for whatever’s already in her hand, and then merrily bang the two similar items together. When she’s a teenager she’ll likely just infuriate me if I see her at all.

But the cold math is the same: Wayfare and I make more than a nanny or daycare service, so Blueberry goes off to the strangers’ arms while we work to keep our heads above water in this crazy world.

An alternative to quitting or taking a full leave of absence — indeed my preferred solution — would be part-time work: ideally I’d work 3-4 days a week, Wayfare would work 2-4, and with one of us having the flexibility to work weekends plus occasional childcare from the grandparents we’d be set. But unfortunately it’s tough to find part-time work — I doubt I’d be able to swing it at my current job, the HR system isn’t really set up for it. Indeed, a 9-day bi-weekly work option (adding ~1 hr to each day and then taking a day off every other week) is a recent experiment there, and that plan’s only around for the summer. Plus there’s too much for me to do to just cut back (though they could almost use another 0.5-0.8 FTE, so perhaps hiring a full-time person and dropping me down to 4 days a week would work for everyone if only the money in the budget could be found).

Health insurance is another hurdle: I get it, Wayfare doesn’t, so it made and continues to make some kind of sense for me to try to keep a stable full-time job while she gets to take the mat/pat leave and spend all the time with Blueberry, even though she’s actually the higher-earner in the family. The value of group insurance for someone so sickly nearly covers the spread in gross pay.

Taking time off would be an easier decision if I had more freelance experience and could use that as essentially a part-time career. Part of what makes me consider it so closely is that I do have some margin of safety in my planning: pushing a planned retirement age from say 60 to 65 is not so bad, not like moving it from 65 to 70 — it’s not like I’d be cutting things so close as to be taking major risks on my ability to work later in life (health, etc.).

Though really as I get more comfortable (even as I write this out) with the idea of sacrificing disposable income and retirement savings to spend time with Blueberry, the big remaining fear is the gap on my resume. It took months to find a decent non-academic job in the first place, and that included accepting the dreaded subway commute. It did kind of backfire on me: part of the reason I went for a non-academic job was to have more stable hours to spend time with my family, and here I am a year later lamenting how little time I manage to spend with my family. Part was for better (short-term) pay: it would have been a lot tighter on a post-doc’s salary, yet here I am considering throwing the financial plan out the window for shits and giggles (literally). With such a gap on my CV and publication record I doubt I would have the option of trying to pursue an academic career now — will it be the same for a non-academic career after a year of being a homemaker?

I just don’t know what to do. I suspect that all my considering and weighing will lead me back to the default choice: keep working, let the woman take the mat/pat leave, and after that let her work part time with hired help to cover the rest of the childcare. It’s kind of sad, but I don’t really see another path…

* – It is apparently babies who confuse birds, planes, and Superman.

Looking for Opportunity in Payout Cuts

May 7th, 2013 by Potato

There is a legitimate reaction of fear and disgust when a dividend-paying company cuts their payout. The cut can often just be the first of a series, and after all, companies that are growing with steady profitability don’t need to cut so it must be a clear sign of trouble. However it’s far from a certain sign: sure, Priszm and Yellow Pages went through a series of cuts before becoming worthless, and investors who bailed at the first cut (or earlier) were in the right — there was not just one cockroach. On the other hand, many companies have a clear plan and future path to follow with a dividend cut, and an over-reaction to the news can be a great buying opportunity.

Superior Plus was recently featured in the Globe and Mail with a very bullish article, yet just after cutting their payout nobody loved it despite the attractive price (indeed, it’s almost doubled from that point). The business was not growing, but it was not crashing at the time of the cut, either. The problem had been too much debt taken on in the past, and no wiggle room with a 100% payout ratio to get it paid off. By slicing the dividend in half, SPB laid out a plan to start paying that debt off in a meaningful way. This was in my opinion the wiser use of their cash, especially given the interest rates they had to pay on the debt. It shouldn’t have been the first cut of many — just a one-off cut, that would likely last for five years or so before going back up. Investors liked the company at $10 before the cut, then even though the underlying business hadn’t changed, were only willing to pay $6 for it after the cut (and now, back to $12).

Similarly, HR.UN had to cut their dividend when capital markets froze up in 2008 and they were caught with their pants down and a half-finished building. They used the cashflow they would have given to unitholders to fund the construction, with a plan to reinstate the dividend at the conclusion of the project. Partly due to this, and partly due to general market uneasiness, there was a point at which you could have bought H&R for roughly a quarter of where it is today. Even if you factor in that the overall market was down roughly 50% at the time, H&R had shed an additional $3/unit. So there might be some value to looking into companies that have recently cut their dividends in case there is an over-correction in the price.

I think Extendicare might fall into this category now. I bought some a few months ago on the thesis that their payout ratio was near the edge: they had refinanced some debt into low-interest long-term form, which is good, but profitability concerns with Medicare cuts left them dancing around the 100% payout mark. I figured they could go either way on a cut, but it would likely be shallow (to get them down to an 80% payout ratio), and that the US and its insurers were likely done trying to squeeze care homes for additional savings. Now clearly I was wrong on the depth of the cut, and possibly on the rounds of cost-cutting coming to an end, but I don’t think this is just the first of many: in the conference call they say that basically they can now fund the payout entirely from the more stable Canadian operations. That should make EXE a pretty decent buy at these levels (<$6). I wouldn’t be too surprised if 2 years from now it’s back at $8 and that‘s when all the bulls come out of the woodwork to exclaim in the press about what a great buy it is at that price.

Any other potential over-corrections to look into out there?