Shoppers Optimum Scam

September 19th, 2012 by Potato

Well, scam is way too harsh, but the hyperbole may be needed to counteract all the “OMG, Shoppers Optimum is the best rewards system!” that’s out there.

I used to love Shoppers; though they’ve long been a terrible pharmacy (high dispensing fees, and we’ve experienced many frustrations with for example filling prescriptions weirdly to generate even more filling fees), I used to think that they were a pretty terrific all-night convenience store: well-lit, well-stocked, with competitive prices. And hey, Optimum.

Then that all started going away: they jacked their prices through the roof, and stopped being well-stocked on sale items. Optimum points were devalued. Customer service took a hit, and many coupons, bonus points, and sale prices were not going through at the register. The one by our house sells out of flyer items sometime before noon on the first day of the sale. I’ve almost entirely stopped shopping there (even though it’s between the bus and my house, so super convenient). To say that it’s one of the best (or to take out the qualifier entirely) because it has the highest percentage return of any loyalty program misses the catch: it’s only good at over-priced Shoppers.

There have been a few times in the recent past when Wayfare has been induced to spend $50-$100 at Shoppers due to a bonus Optimum points event. As Wayfare puts it, she only shops there on 20X the points events, and redeems her points on bonus redemption days. “It’s like 30% off!” On the surface, that looks approximately correct: you normally earn 10 points per dollar spent (truncated — so $17.40 pre-tax gets you 170 points), and points are “worth” $0.00179 each if you save up to the top tier. That works out to about 1.79% return on normal days, and as much as 42% if you only buy on 20X the points days and only redeem on bonus redemption days, and then spend exactly $200 (and not pick up a bunch of overpriced crap that you pay for at the regular rate once you’re past $200). Compare that to the ~1% you get with PC points (and only then if you qualify for the special card) or the 0.5% from Air Miles (though it may be even less than that now with the constant devaluing of points).

Here’s my thinking: yes, you get “money” back, but you can only use it at Shoppers, which is ludicrously over-priced. So you get your 30-42% back in points (including the bonus redemption at the high end), but then you have to spend those points on stuff that’s 30-42% over-priced.

I had in my head that Shoppers was roughly 30% over-priced, but I hadn’t checked it explicitly in a while. So tonight when I went shopping, I did a price comparison on a basket of 11 items at Shoppers and Real Canadian Super Store (RCSS — basically Loblaws), chosen quasirandomly (I wandered around the store and wrote down the price of stuff I might find on my shopping list, and stuck to name brands so I could compare across stores). The average was actually that Shoppers was 42% more expensive than RCSS (data at the end).

So, even on the most fortuitous bonus points days at Shoppers (20X) you spend $1.42 to get $1 worth of stuff, and also pick up $.60 in Optimum points, which you later spend to get $.42 worth of stuff. In the end, you spent $1.42 to get $1.42 worth of stuff — but paid tax on $2.02. That tax hit would mean that you’d be behind by $0.078, or just over 5%. You go to all the trouble of shopping on the 20X the points days, then saving up your points for the top tier and a bonus redemption day, and then run around the store with a notepad and calculator so you’re sure to spend as close to $200 as humanly possible… and you end up 5% behind the ball. Could have just gone to RCSS and bought on any old day (and received a bonus 1% in PC points).

To be fair, Shoppers does put stuff on sale on top of the Optimum offers… but RCSS puts stuff on sale, too, so again it’s one less variable to worry about. You could do better if the Shoppers sale price is down to the RCSS sale price and you get some kind of bonus points event (either on the collection or redemption side), but will that be true of everything you put in your cart? Sometimes, yes: when I do stoop to shopping at Shoppers, it’s to scoop up the loss leaders that are actually cheaper than other stores, and that is usually all I’ll buy. Coke and facial tissues are perennial loss leader favourites at Shoppers — though as I said above, I can’t actually do that at the store near my house since they sell out (or, as far as I can tell, never carried any inventory in the first place).

The high percentage return of Optimum really masks what a mediocre deal it is, since everything is marked up to account for that Optimum payback (which means you’re doubly screwed if you ever shop there when you’re not getting bonus points, or if you forget your card).

Items Shoppers RCSS
Nestle 90 pc Halloween chocolate $17.99 $14.97 20%
Bandaid Wetflex 45s $8.99 $5.49 64%
Tyelenol extra strength EZ tabs 150s $17.99 $12.99 38%
Tums 750 mg x 100 $5.59 $3.79 47%
Fusion shave creme $7.49 $5.99 25%
Crest mouthwash 1L $8.49 $6.49 31%
Degree deodorant $4.79 $3.49 37%
Softsoap 590mL refill $5.99 $3.79 58%
Dove shampoo 355mL $7.99 $4.99 60%
Huggies baby wipes (naturals) 184 pk $10.99 $6.97 58%
Huggies lil movers diapers 72/90 box $27.99 $18.74* 49%
Total $124.29 $87.70 42%

* – the box of Huggies in Shoppers was a 72-pack, but RCSS didn’t sell that size. The closest was a 90-pack for $23.43, so I took the price per diaper, multiplied that by 72, and put it in to get a fair comparison to Shoppers.

Blueberry Portfolio Month 4 – Whiterock Luck

September 16th, 2012 by Potato

This is a monthly update from the Blueberry Portfolio. The events I mention below happened approx 8 months ago.

In my last report I didn’t have much to say, and the market as a whole has been pretty boring since then too.

It’s been a touch more exciting in our investment portfolio the last two weeks. We now stand at over a 15% return since inception, vs. the TSX at just over 1%.

Generally, things are working out quite well (with of course a few exceptions). In particular, Whiterock REIT was climbing up above the $14 mark in the month, which raises the eternal debate with these kinds of stocks: should we take the quick capital gain, or continue to hold for the distribution?

There is always some measure of uncertainty when valuing a stock, and transaction fees are a drag, so the strategy in general is to buy when undervalued, and hold until you think the risk starts to outweigh the opportunity — ideally forever otherwise. But I thought that I had a pretty good handle on Whiterock: I was happy to buy lots of it at any price below $12, considered it fairly valued in the $12-14 range, and much above $14 it started to look a little pricey. That is, in my opinion, an extraordinarily narrow range for valuations, and I was perhaps being a little too precise. To put it in terms of expected future returns, the difference between the high and low points would be the difference in earning 9.3% or 8.0% — quite a narrow range indeed. Nonetheless, once the price hit $14 the “maybe it’s time to sell” gears started turning in my head.

Considering we had almost a 20% gain on it in just 4 months, I gave serious consideration to taking the quick capital gain, and ended up putting in an order to sell one night. Fortunately we got lucky, because rather than selling for $14.50 Dundee came along with a takeover offer that very morning, and we ended up getting $16.05 for the shares — a 10% extra gain just by pure dumb luck.

Once again though I find myself without many good ideas. The market has recovered a lot from the October lows, and isn’t presenting a lot of opportunities. Last time around I increased the position sizes of the ideas I did have, but I can’t keep pushing that strategy or we’ll end up with just 4 or 5 concentrated names, and I’m not comfortable with that. As it is, Chemtrade has continued to perform well, giving us another 6% return in the last 2 weeks. If this continues I *will* be trimming back: as much as I like the stock, as high as my “price target” or the upper range of my fair valuation estimate is, and as much as we’re “playing with the winnings” here, I simply don’t like the idea of having more than 20% of the portfolio in any one position. I have a large reading list ahead of me which may prove fruitful, but in the meantime we will deviate from the plan to remain nearly totally invested.

Freddie Mac: Political Risk

August 18th, 2012 by Potato

When I first talked about Freddie Mac, political risk was one of the things I highlighted that might undermine what otherwise looked like an attractive long-shot bet. The US government has been requiring that Freddie Mac (and its sibling GSE, Fannie Mae) borrow more money than they need, and pay a punitive 10% interest rate on that — a worse deal than the TBTF banks who arguably had more to do with the cause of the global financial crisis. Part of what lead to the excess borrowing was the fact that Freddie’s been over-reserving for years now. It looks as though they’re getting to the point where even the most conservative accountants realize that those excess reserves will start unwinding, which will enable Freddie to start paying back the government — and after that, the preferred shareholders.

So it looks like the main investing thesis was playing out.

Unfortunately that political risk reared it’s head this week as the government announced it would change the deal to instead confiscate all future profits. I have no idea why the government decided to nationalize the GSEs but not AIG or the TBTF banks, or why they decided to change the deal at this late stage, just as the profitability was re-emerging. I suppose I’ll just have to pray they don’t decide to alter the deal any further.

I’m not quite sure what that means in terms of the preferreds being paid back, but my first take on it is that they’ll be worthless. The market seems to be equally panicked, as most issues were down about 60% on Friday.

Blueberry Portfolio Month 3: Capital Gains

August 13th, 2012 by Potato

This is a monthly update from the Blueberry Portfolio. The events I mention below happened approx 8 months ago.

I started this update by providing a spreadsheet to the investors with the capital gains laid out. [Specifics redacted] It’s important to remember that realized gains in a non-registered account are taxable. Add the information from the spreadsheet to your schedule 3 for taxes (if you don’t ordinarily have gains to put in schedule 3, I can show you how, it’s really easy). In addition, you’ll be receiving some tax slips (T3s) in the mail around the beginning of March for the dividends that you enter into the appropriate boxes in your tax software.

Otherwise there hasn’t been much to say.

After spending some time without (m)any bright ideas, I put more cash into the ideas I did have. That broke an unwritten rule that I’d try to stay diversified with no more than 10-15% in any one stock (Chemtrade is close to 20% of the portfolio, and Canexus over 10% — and both are in disturbingly similar businesses). As soon as I do have a bright idea, these will be the first positions I look to trim to get cash to move around.

One bright idea was Poseidon: a high-risk, high-reward play on “fraccing” in the oil business, which also pays a lucrative dividend. Our timing there couldn’t have been much better: as of this message, we’re already up about 15%. I don’t know yet how much further I’ll let this one run before locking in the profits, but I imagine I’ll wait for at least double that return over the next year before getting out (unless something changes).

Since the last monthly update, the market has been more-or-less flat, while we’ve added a few percentage points. After the first day of trading in the new year, we’re up almost exactly 10%, vs the market at just about 1%.

All-In-One Mortgage Accounts

July 27th, 2012 by Potato

There are some readvancable mortgages that are sometimes billed as all-in-one accounts at a few different institutions. The way they work is to basically pull together your mortgage, line of credit, savings, and chequing accounts into one product. The stated benefit is that your emergency fund and cash float from your savings and chequing accounts will be used to pay down the mortgage, but are still available for your use as needed.

All else being equal, this would be a great idea, and indeed recently Nelson at Financial Uproar had a post covering them.

The problem though is that these products usually come with a higher interest rate than you could get on a plain vanilla mortgage, about 0.5-1% more. So does the benefit of having your whole float working on your mortgage balance outweigh the extra cost of the higher interest rate? Like many things, the answer is it depends… but mostly, no.

You can grab a spreadsheet and play along at home with the full calculations if you like, but for once I’m just going to back-of-the-envelope it. There will be some minor effects from the compounding, but not enough to really worry about.

So let’s say you’re a fairly typical recent homeowner: you bought a few years ago, and just recently crossed over into having enough equity to try out this scheme. You’ve got $10k in your emergency fund, and your chequing account balance varies through the month depending on the timing of your bills and payroll deposits, but is on average about $3k. So you could potentially put an additional $13k towards your mortgage with this plan. If you’ve got $400k left on your mortgage, then the amount of interest you’d pay in a year would be $12k at 3%. With the new plan, you’d only be paying interest on $387k, but at the higher rate of 3.5%, which would cost you $13.5k. So the higher interest rate makes it a fair bit more expensive to go with this plan (and any impact of compounding would be balanced by the interest the cash would be generating in a savings account).

If you have more in cash and less owing on your house, it may look better: with $20k in cash and only $100k owing on the mortgage, you’d be paying $3k in interest the traditional way, versus $2.8k for the all-in-one. Still, you need almost absurd amounts of cash compared to the mortgage balance for it to work out.

Plus, with just a little bit of effort on your part, you could in those situations do even better with separate accounts: you can get a regular mortgage at the lower rate, put all of that cash on the mortgage, and open a separate HELOC to get the flexibility to re-withdraw your emergency fund if and when needed. All the money goes on the mortgage at the lower rate — you can even put your chequing account float on the mortgage and use the HELOC for the revolving cash needs (which sounds scary, but is functionally exactly what is happening with the all-in-one products).